Market Value Guide
Real market data from 78 active listings. Know what a 2021 tesla model-y is really worth before you buy.
Data refreshed daily from AutoTrader
Sample Size
78
listings analyzed
Average Price
$28,199
from $19,000 to $37,995
Median Price
$28,380
above average
Avg Mileage
16,326 mi
for 2021
The 2021 tesla model-y has an average market price of $28,199 based on 78 active listings on AutoTrader. Prices range from $19,000 to $37,995, with a median of $28,380. The middle 50% of listings fall between $25,991 and $30,494, representing the typical fair market range. The average mileage across all 2021 tesla model-y listings is 16,326 miles. Use SmartCarAgent to analyze a specific 2021 tesla model-y listing and get a personalized Deal Score, market comparison, and AI negotiation tips.
Based on 78 active listings, the 2021 tesla model-y market price ranges from $19,000 to $37,995. The median price is $28,380, giving you a clear benchmark for negotiations.
A fair deal typically falls between $25,991 and $30,494 — that's the middle 50% of transactions. Listings under $25,991 are rare finds worth grabbing quickly.
When evaluating a 2021 tesla model-y, check the service history and look for consistent maintenance records. Vehicles with complete service documentation typically command higher prices and are less likely to have hidden issues.
The 78 listings in our database include a wide range of conditions and mileages. Use the mileage (16,326 mi average for this segment) as one indicator of wear — lower-mileage examples generally cost more upfront but may save on repairs long-term.
SmartCarAgent tip: Always verify the VIN history and consider a third-party inspection before purchasing any used vehicle.
Bottom 25%
Under $25,991
Great deals
Mid 50% (Fair Range)
$25,991 – $30,494
Typical market pricing
Top 25%
Over $30,494
Overpriced
| Year | Listings | Avg Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 tesla model-y | 43 | $46,748 |
| 2025 tesla model-y | 30 | $39,933 |
| 2024 tesla model-y | 97 | $37,312 |
| 2023 tesla model-y | 134 | $33,195 |
| 2022 tesla model-y | 69 | $32,073 |
| 2021 tesla model-y | 78 | $28,199 |
| 2020 tesla model-y | 21 | $27,019 |
Paste the URL and get an instant Deal Score, market comparison, AI report, and negotiation tips.
Works with any AutoTrader or CarGurus listing
[email protected] · © 2026 SmartCarAgent. All rights reserved.
AI-powered used car deal analysis